Is Tua Tagovailoa better than Aaron Rodgers at this stage of their careers?

On the latest episode of the Move the Sticks podcast with former NFL scout Daniel Jeremiah and former NFL player Bucky Brooks, the duo ranked the quarterbacks of the AFC East from worst to first, and Miami Dolphins starting quarterback Tua Tagovailoa came in second, just behind the Buffalo Bills’ Josh Allen.

Both analysts ranked Allen first, Tagovailoa second, Aaron Rodgers of the New York Jets third, and Jacoby Brissett of the New England Patriots in the fourth and final position.

Here’s what Jeremiah had to say about Tagovailoa ranking higher than future Hall of Fame quarterback Aaron Rodgers:

“The conversation and debate is Tua versus Aaron and when you factor in health and recent performance and expectations of where they are, I don’t — I couldn’t get myself — I respect Aaron and what he’s done and accomplished, but I couldn’t — I couldn’t — put him down over Tua based off of recent history.”

Brooks followed Jeremiah with his assessment.

“Yeah, it’s hard. I mean, you’d be giving a lifetime achievement award. Tua’s numbers are what they are and his production and performance on the field certainly merits him being in that conversation. Is he an all-timer? Is he a top-five quarterback in this league? I would say no, but it’s hard to dispute what he’s been able to do with the weapons around him and in the offense that Mike McDaniel has, so you’ve got to give him his flowers.”

To listen to the entire episode, click this link.

___

Do you agree with Jeremiah and Brooks’ rankings? Do you think that Tagovailoa should be ranked higher than Rodgers? Do you think that Tagovailoa should be the number one quarterback in the AFC East division? Let me know in the comments below or on Twitter/X at @MBrave13!